RS 42:1141     

  

SUBPART B. PROCEDURE

§1141. Complaints and investigations

            A.(1) The Board of Ethics members may sit en banc or in panels in such order and at such times as the board directs.

            (2) The Board of Ethics may authorize the hearing and determination of matters by separate panels, each consisting of not less than three members. Such panels shall sit at the times and places to hear matters assigned as the chairman directs. Such hearings shall be public except those provided for in Subsection C of this Section. All determinations of a panel shall be by a majority vote. However, if a panel consists of three members, all determinations of the panel shall require a unanimous vote of the members of the panel. Each panel shall be vested with specific subject matter jurisdiction. The Board of Ethics may determine by rule a procedure to rotate members among different subject matter panels to encourage the participation of each member of the board in, and the knowledge of each member of the board of, matters concerning the different provisions of law under the jurisdiction of the board.

            (3) Notwithstanding any other provision of this Chapter, the presence of eleven members shall be required to conduct the business of the Board of Ethics sitting en banc.

            (4) The Board of Ethics shall promulgate procedural and jurisdictional rules relative to the establishment of the several panels. The rules shall specify procedures wherein the chairman may refer matters to the appropriate panel with proper subject matter jurisdiction.

            (5) The Board of Ethics by a majority vote of its membership, may review any opinion, decision, finding, or ruling of any panel.

            B.(1)(a) The Board of Ethics shall consider any signed sworn complaint from any elector, hereinafter referred to as complainant, concerning a violation of this Chapter which is within its jurisdiction or the regulations or orders issued by the Board of Ethics, or may, by a two-thirds majority vote of its membership, consider any matter which it has reason to believe may be a violation of this Chapter. Additionally, the board may consider any matter which it has reason to believe may be a violation of any other provision of law within its jurisdiction as provided in this Subsection or as may be otherwise provided by law. However, the board shall not use information contained in a request for an advisory opinion as the basis to initiate an investigation.

            (b) The board, after considering the matter, shall determine by a two-thirds majority vote of its membership whether there is probable cause to believe that a violation of this Chapter or other law within the board's jurisdiction has occurred. In determining probable cause, the board shall consider whether the totality of known circumstances is sufficient to justify the belief that the respondent has committed a violation.

            (c)(i) If the board determines that there is probable cause to believe that a violation has occurred, a certified copy of the vote; a detailed explanation of the matter including the specific factual allegations upon which the board based its decision to investigate; and a copy of any complaint received by the board, from which the name of the complainant has been redacted, shall be sent by certified mail to the accused and the complainant within ten days after the vote occurs or after receipt of a signed sworn complaint.

            (ii) The detailed explanation of the matter shall be prefaced by advising the respondent that he may exercise his constitutional right to counsel and may exercise his constitutional right not to incriminate himself.

            (d) The chairman of the Board of Ethics may assign a matter to the appropriate panel for investigation, in which case the panel shall conduct a private investigation to elicit evidence upon which the panel shall determine whether to recommend to the board that a public hearing be conducted or that a violation has not occurred.

            (e) The board shall provide a person who has filed a non-sworn complaint with only a notification stating the final disposition of the complaint.

            (2) A notice or report sent to the board by the legislative auditor or the inspector general may be treated by the board as a matter for consideration in accordance with the provisions of this Subsection.

            (3) Any person who, with knowledge of its falsity, makes a false complaint shall be subject to the penalties set forth in R.S. 42:1153.

            C.(1)(a) Upon determining that an investigation is warranted as provided in Subsection B of this Section, a private investigation shall be conducted to elicit evidence upon which the Board of Ethics shall determine whether a public hearing should be conducted or that a violation has not occurred. The accused and the complainant shall be given written notification of the commencement of the investigation not less than ten days prior to the date set for the commencement of the investigation.

            (b)(i) For purposes of an investigation, the Board of Ethics or the ethics administrator may require the submission under oath of written reports or answers to questions, or subpoena or compel the production of any books, records, and papers which the board or the ethics administrator deems relevant or material to the investigation or hearing. The board or ethics administrator shall require the submission under oath of written reports or answers to questions, or subpoena or compel the production of any books, records, and papers only upon a finding that the importance of the information sought outweighs the burden of producing the information.

            (ii) The ethics administrator shall provide to the Board of Ethics a monthly report of the number of subpoenas issued by the board and the ethics administrator in the prior month.

            (c) The subject of the investigation or any witness upon whom written questions have been propounded shall serve a copy of the written answers and objections, if any, within thirty days after the service of the questions.

            (d) The subject of the investigation or any witness upon whom a subpoena has been served to compel the production of books, records, or papers shall serve a copy of the responses and objections, if any, within thirty days after the service of the subpoena.

            (e) The subject of the investigation or any witness upon whom a subpoena has been served requiring the submission under oath of written reports shall produce the written reports within thirty days after the service of the subpoena.

            (f) The Board of Ethics shall promptly provide the subject of the investigation with a copy of questions propounded or subpoenas served upon any witness, as well as any answers, objections, books, records, or papers, or written reports produced, or transcripts or recordings of answers to questions produced under oath.

            (g) Any demand, request, or subpoena propounded upon the subject of the investigation or witness, orally or in writing, shall be prefaced by advising the subject of the investigation or witness that he may exercise his constitutional right to counsel and may exercise his constitutional right not to incriminate himself.

            (h) An oral examination under oath shall be conducted under conditions agreed upon by the subject of the investigation or witness, including that the examination occur in a certain place, at a certain time, or by phone or videoconference, and with counsel present, that the examination be transcribed or audio recorded, and that the subject of the investigation or witness promptly receive a copy of the transcript or audio recording.

            (i) The Board of Ethics shall adopt rules providing for discovery consistent with Chapter 3 of Title III of Book II of the Code of Civil Procedure and as constrained by this Subsection, to the extent and in the manner appropriate to its proceedings.

            (2)(a) The Board of Ethics shall, after the investigation and prior to determining whether a hearing should be conducted, grant the person subject to the investigation an opportunity to address, orally or in writing, the final report of the staff, the information gathered during the investigation, and any factual or legal issues relevant to the alleged violation by the person subject to the investigation.

            (b) The Board of Ethics shall, at the election of the person subject to the investigation, permit the person to address the board in person, by telephone, or by videoconference.

            D.(1)(a) In case of contumacy or refusal to obey a subpoena issued to any public servant or other person, any district court of this state within the jurisdiction of which the public servant or other person resides, upon application by the Board of Ethics shall have jurisdiction to issue to such public servant or other person an order requiring him to produce books, records, or papers, or to require the submission under oath of written reports or answers to questions concerning the matter under consideration.

            (b) The district court shall subpoena or compel the production of books, records, or papers, or require the submission under oath of written reports or answers to questions, only upon a finding that the importance of the information sought outweighs the burden of producing the information.

            (2) Upon motion by the subject of the investigation, a prospective witness, or any person whose books, records, papers, or other documents are the subject of any subpoena, and for good cause shown, any district court within the jurisdiction of which the movant resides may make any order which justice requires to protect such person from undue burden or expense, including one or more of the following:

            (a) That the inquiry not be had.

            (b) That the inquiry may be had only upon specified terms and conditions including a designation of the time and place.

            (c) That the inquiry shall be conducted by a method other than selected by the Board of Ethics.

            (d) That certain matters not be inquired into or that the scope of the inquiry be limited to certain matters.

            (e) That the inquiry be conducted with no one present except persons designated by the court.

            (3) The Board of Ethics shall waive, upon written request by the affected party, any right to be served by any means other than email transmission, and shall provide an email address at which the Board of Ethics shall accept service.

            (4) Any failure to obey such order of the court may be deemed by the district court to be contempt of court.

            (5) The district court, upon denying any application made pursuant to this Subsection, may order the movant to pay the court costs and attorney fees of the prevailing party.

            E.(1) After the investigation has been completed, the Board of Ethics shall, by vote of two-thirds of its members, determine whether a public hearing before the Ethics Adjudicatory Board should be conducted to receive evidence and to determine whether any violation of any provision of law within its jurisdiction has occurred.

            (2) Before the board determines whether a public hearing should be conducted to receive evidence, the board shall:

            (a) Provide the subject of the investigation with the final report of the staff of the board to the board regarding the investigation of the alleged violation by the subject of the investigation.

            (b) Provide the subject of the investigation with an opportunity to submit a brief response to the final report of the staff.

            (c) Provide the subject of the investigation with an opportunity to briefly make a statement before the Board of Ethics to address the final report of the staff and any factual or legal issues relevant to the alleged violation by the subject of the investigation. Such statements may be presented in person, by telephone, or by videoconference during executive session of the Board of Ethics, unless the subject of the investigation requests that his comments be made in open session. Statements by the subject of the investigation before the Board of Ethics in executive session shall not be recorded.

            (3) If the Board of Ethics determines a violation has not occurred, the subject of the investigation and the complainant shall be notified within ten days of the board's determination.

            F.(1) If the board determines following an investigation that a public hearing should be conducted, the board shall issue charges. A public hearing shall be conducted to receive evidence relative to the facts alleged in the charges and to determine whether any violation of any provision of law within the jurisdiction of the board has occurred. The public hearing on such charges shall be conducted by the Ethics Adjudicatory Board in accordance with the Administrative Procedure Act and this Part.

            (2) The charges issued by the board shall contain each of the following:

            (a) A plain, concise, and definite written statement of the essential facts constituting the alleged violation.

            (b) The official or customary citation of the statute which is alleged to have been violated.

            (c) The date of the meeting at which the board voted to issue charges.

            (d) The name of the trial attorney, if designated.

            (e) A written statement advising the respondent that he may exercise his constitutional right to counsel and may exercise his constitutional right not to incriminate himself.

            G. If the Board of Ethics does not issue charges within one year from the date upon which a sworn complaint is received or, if no sworn complaint was received, within one year from the date the board voted to consider the matter, the matter shall be dismissed. The one-year period is prescriptive. The prescriptive period may be suspended, interrupted, or renounced. The prescriptive period shall be suspended by any of the following:

            (1) The person who is the subject of the investigation or complaint files any pleading or proceeding in a state or federal court or with the Ethics Adjudicatory Board related to the matter under investigation that has the effect of delaying or impeding the proceeding.

            (2) The person who is the subject of the investigation or complaint fails to comply with a subpoena or other request from the Board of Ethics for information related to or in connection with the investigation of the Board of Ethics.

            (3) The person who is the subject of the investigation or complaint may consent in writing to the suspension of the prescriptive period.

            (4) Determinations concerning the prescriptive period provided for in this Subsection shall be made by the Ethics Adjudicatory Board.

            H. The Board of Ethics shall consider offering a consent opinion to each person who is the subject of an investigation.

            Acts 1979, No. 443, §1, eff. April 1, 1980. Amended by Acts 1980, No. 579, §1; Acts 1980, No. 580, §1; Acts 1987, No. 730, §1; Acts 1996, 1st Ex. Sess., No. 64, §6, eff. Jan. 1, 1997; Acts 1997, No. 1303, §1; Acts 2001, No. 384, §1; Acts 2008, 1st Ex. Sess., No. 23, §1, eff. Aug. 15, 2008; Acts 2008, No. 128, §1; Acts 2008, No. 595, §1; Acts 2010, No. 1002, §1, eff. July 8, 2010; Acts 2010, No. 861, §22; Acts 2012, No. 608, §§1, 2, eff. June 7, 2012; Acts 2024, No. 591, §1; Acts 2025, No. 301, §1, eff. June 11, 2025.

NOTE: See Acts 1997, No. 1303, §§2 and 3, for effectiveness of Paragraph (B)(3).

NOTE: See Acts 2012, No.608, §3, relative to the prospective application of Act and the application of R.S. 42:1141(C)(3)(c) and amended by the Act.